top of page

A review of DP v. Grand Erie District School Board

The Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario recently released a decision in the case of DP v. Grand Erie District School Board, in which the applicant alleged discrimination with respect to services on the grounds of race, colour, sex, family status, and marital status.


The applicant's son attended an elementary school operated by the respondent school board. The applicant alleged that the school discriminated against him by making unfounded allegations about his behaviour, playing on negative stereotypes about non-custodial fathers and individuals of Jamaican descent. As a result, the applicant claimed that the school prohibited him from picking up his son directly from the school.


In her decision, Adjudicator Jessica Connell found that the respondent school board had indeed discriminated against the applicant on the grounds of race, colour, and family status. Connell also found that the respondent had failed to accommodate the applicant's family status.


The decision highlights the importance of ensuring that schools do not discriminate against parents on the basis of their race, colour, or family status, and that they provide appropriate accommodations for parents with non-traditional custody arrangements.

One of the key lessons that Ontario public schools can learn from this case is the need to carefully consider the potential impacts of their actions on parents, particularly those with non-traditional custody arrangements. In this case, the respondent school board's decision to prohibit the applicant from picking up his son directly from the school had a significant impact on the applicant's ability to exercise his parenting time.


Additionally, the decision underscores the importance of avoiding stereotypes and biases when interacting with parents. The respondent school board's reliance on negative stereotypes about non-custodial fathers and individuals of Jamaican descent ultimately led to discrimination against the applicant.


It is crucial that schools take steps to address and prevent discrimination and bias in all of their interactions with parents and guardians. This can include providing training for staff on issues related to discrimination and bias, as well as implementing policies and procedures to ensure that all parents are treated equally and with respect.


Overall, the DP v. Grand Erie District School Board decision serves as an important reminder of the need for Ontario public schools to prioritize inclusivity and equal treatment for all parents and guardians. By taking steps to prevent discrimination and bias, and by providing appropriate accommodations for parents with non-traditional custody arrangements, schools can help to ensure that all families have access to the support and resources they need to ensure the success of their children.

bottom of page